“It’s a Magic Word:” Tweets from the Eminently Quotable DOMA Oral Argument

You are viewing an old revision of this post, from March 27, 2013 @ 13:12:53. See below for differences between this version and the current revision.

Today, the Supreme Court heard two hours of arguments in United States v. Windsor, with fifty minutes allotted on the technical question of standing–namely, whether the DOMA case should even be before the Supreme Court at all–and sixty minutes on the merits. Though the Prop 8 case on Tuesday seemed to get the lion’s share of media attention–pictures of the line and the protests outside the Courthouse this morning show a smaller audience than yesterday’s–initial reactions and reports indicate that the DOMA argument and subsequent press conference from plaintiff Edie Windsor are 10000% more quotable. A collection of tweets recapping the day’s events:

Post Revisions:

Changes:

March 27, 2013 @ 13:12:53Current Revision
Content
Deleted: Today, the Supreme Court heard two hours of arguments in United States v. Windsor, with fifty minutes allotted on the technical question of standing--namely, whether the DOMA case should even be before the Supreme Court at all--and sixty minutes on the merits. Though the Prop 8 case on Tuesday seemed to get the lion's share of media attention--pictures of the line and the protests outside the Courthouse this morning show a smaller audience than yesterday's--initial reactions and reports indicate that the DOMA argument and subsequent press conference from plaintiff Edie Windsor are 10000% more quotable. A collection of tweets recapping the day's events: Added: Today, the Supreme Court heard two hours of arguments in <em>United States v. Windsor</em>, with fifty minutes allotted on the technical question of standing--namely, whether the DOMA case should even be before the Supreme Court at all--and sixty minutes on the merits. Though the Prop 8 case on Tuesday seemed to get the lion's share of media attention--pictures of the line and the protests outside the Courthouse this morning show a smaller audience than yesterday's--initial reactions and reports indicate that the DOMA argument and subsequent press conference from plaintiff Edie Windsor are 10,000% more quotable. A collection of tweets recapping the day's events:
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>The long line for <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23Scotus" >#Scotus</a> DOMA arguments. Smaller less-festive crowd than yesterday Prop8 masses<a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23GayMarriage" >#GayMarriage</a> <a href="http:// t.co/h2BRBS5z85" title="http:/ /twitter.com/ evanperez/status/ 316903970499072000/photo/ 1">twitter.com/evanperez/ stat…</a></p>&mdash; Evan Pérez (@evanperez) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ evanperez/status/ 316903970499072000">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> Added: <blockquote class="twitter-tweet">The long line for <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23Scotus" >#Scotus</a> DOMA arguments. Smaller less-festive crowd than yesterday Prop8 masses<a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23GayMarriage" >#GayMarriage</a> <a title="http:/ /twitter.com/ evanperez/status/ 316903970499072000/photo/1" href="http:// t.co/h2BRBS5z85" >twitter.com/ evanperez/stat…</a>
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Litttttle bit awkward: Westboro Baptist Church folks standing right next to gay marriage supporters. <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a> <a href="http:// t.co/qVifxUzuoF" title="http:/ /twitter.com/ jbendery/status/ 316912824490283010/photo/ 1">twitter.com/ jbendery/statu…< /a></p>&mdash; jennifer bendery (@jbendery) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ jbendery/status/ 316912824490283010">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
 Added: — Evan Pérez (@evanperez) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ evanperez/status/ 316903970499072000">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Litttttle bit awkward: Westboro Baptist Church folks standing right next to gay marriage supporters. <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a> <a title="http:/ /twitter.com/ jbendery/status/ 316912824490283010/photo/1" href="http:// t.co/qVifxUzuoF" >twitter.com/ jbendery/statu…</a>
 Added: — jennifer bendery (@jbendery) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ jbendery/status/ 316912824490283010">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>For two <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a> lawyers, Vicki Jackson, Harvard law prof, and Roberta Kaplan, big-firm partner, it's their first <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23SCOTUS" >#SCOTUS</a> arguments. <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23nerves" >#nerves</a></p>&mdash; frajam (@frajam) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ frajam/status/ 316924438178320385">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> Added: <blockquote class="twitter-tweet">For two <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a> lawyers, Vicki Jackson, Harvard law prof, and Roberta Kaplan, big-firm partner, it's their first <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23SCOTUS" >#SCOTUS</a> arguments. <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23nerves" >#nerves</a>
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Chief Roberts: To agree with lower court that <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a> is unconstitutional yet enforcing the law is "unprecedented" <a href="http:// t.co/5al13LjyZk" title="http:/ /ow.ly/jsZwh" >ow.ly/jsZwh< /a></p>&mdash; JamesVGrimaldi (@JamesVGrimaldi) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ JamesVGrimaldi/ status/316930277748383746">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Kennedy likens Obama admin's enforce-but-don't-defend DOMA stance to executive abuse via signing statements. "It's very troubling."</p>&mdash; Damon Root (@damonroot) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ damonroot/status/ 316953646283763712">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Roberts asks why Obama enforces DOMA if he thinks it's unconstitutional. "I don’t see why he doesn’t have the courage of his convictions.”</p>&mdash; Peter Baker (@peterbakernyt) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ peterbakernyt/ status/316949954721632258">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Kagan suggested DOMA's passage was "infected with animus, with fear, with dislike."</p>&mdash; Sahil Kapur (@sahilkapur) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ sahilkapur/status/ 316947497467650048">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Justice Ginsburg asks, “What kind of marriage is this?” Points out gay couples denied tax treatment, benefits <a href="http:// t.co/t0GagUytSe" title="http:/ /on.wsj.com/XeyL5A" >on.wsj.com/XeyL5A</a> <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23scotus" >#scotus</a></p>&mdash; Rubina Madan Fillion (@rubinafillion) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ rubinafillion/ status/316944876459663360">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Roberts: Politicians are "falling all over themselves" to endorse same sex marriage so gays and lesbians have to be "politically powerful"</p>&mdash; AdamSerwer (@AdamSerwer) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ AdamSerwer/status/ 316947544800378881">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Ginsburg: Lack of federal benefits creates a two-tiered system - "full marriage and the skim-milk marriage." <a href="http:// t.co/gTgIWKUMXx" title="http:/ /wapo.st/Yft4UC" >wapo.st/Yft4UC</a> <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA" >#DOMA</a></p>&mdash; The Washington Post (@washingtonpost) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ washingtonpost/ status/316950984276467712">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Kennedy to Clement: "I see illogic in your argument." <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a> <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23SCOTUS" >#SCOTUS</a></p>&mdash; Ryan J. Reilly (@ryanjreilly) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ ryanjreilly/ status/316950489570881539">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>The @<a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ guardian">guardian</a> SCOTUS live blog of the DOMA case is priceless: <a href="http:// t.co/lKZhk3tXv6" title="http:/ /twitter.com/ jaypinho/status/ 316951493582409730/photo/ 1">twitter.com/ jaypinho/statu…< /a></p>&mdash; Jay Pinho (@jaypinho) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ jaypinho/status/ 316951493582409730">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Roberts seemed deeply offended at the idea that Congress barred fed recognition of same sex marriages because they don't like gay people</p>&mdash; AdamSerwer (@AdamSerwer) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ AdamSerwer/status/ 316952171759407104">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Kennedy cares deeply about federalism issues (more than Robts). Tells atty defending DOMA marriage "always considered a state police power."</p>&mdash; Jan Crawford (@JanCBS) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ JanCBS/status/ 316950834334281729">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
 Added: — frajam (@frajam) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ frajam/status/ 316924438178320385">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Chief Roberts: To agree with lower court that <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a> is unconstitutional yet enforcing the law is "unprecedented" <a title="http:/ /ow.ly/jsZwh" href="http:// t.co/5al13LjyZk" >ow.ly/jsZwh</a>
 Added: — JamesVGrimaldi (@JamesVGrimaldi) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ JamesVGrimaldi/ status/316930277748383746">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Kennedy likens Obama admin's enforce-but-don't-defend DOMA stance to executive abuse via signing statements. "It's very troubling."
 Added: — Damon Root (@damonroot) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ damonroot/status/ 316953646283763712">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Roberts asks why Obama enforces DOMA if he thinks it's unconstitutional. "I don’t see why he doesn’t have the courage of his convictions.”
 Added: — Peter Baker (@peterbakernyt) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ peterbakernyt/ status/316949954721632258">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Kagan suggested DOMA's passage was "infected with animus, with fear, with dislike."
 Added: — Sahil Kapur (@sahilkapur) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ sahilkapur/status/ 316947497467650048">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Justice Ginsburg asks, “What kind of marriage is this?” Points out gay couples denied tax treatment, benefits <a title="http:/ /on.wsj.com/XeyL5A" href="http:// t.co/t0GagUytSe" >on.wsj.com/XeyL5A</a> <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23scotus" >#scotus</a>
 Added: — Rubina Madan Fillion (@rubinafillion) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ rubinafillion/ status/316944876459663360">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Roberts: Politicians are "falling all over themselves" to endorse same sex marriage so gays and lesbians have to be "politically powerful"
 Added: — AdamSerwer (@AdamSerwer) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ AdamSerwer/status/ 316947544800378881">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Ginsburg: Lack of federal benefits creates a two-tiered system - "full marriage and the skim-milk marriage." <a title="http:/ /wapo.st/Yft4UC" href="http:// t.co/gTgIWKUMXx" >wapo.st/Yft4UC</a> <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a>
 Added: — The Washington Post (@washingtonpost) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ washingtonpost/ status/316950984276467712">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Kennedy to Clement: "I see illogic in your argument." <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a> <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23SCOTUS" >#SCOTUS</a>
 Added: — Ryan J. Reilly (@ryanjreilly) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ ryanjreilly/ status/316950489570881539">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter-tweet">The @<a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ guardian">guardian</a> SCOTUS live blog of the DOMA case is priceless: <a title="http:/ /twitter.com/ jaypinho/status/ 316951493582409730/photo/1" href="http:// t.co/lKZhk3tXv6" >twitter.com/ jaypinho/statu…</a>
 Added: — Jay Pinho (@jaypinho) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ jaypinho/status/ 316951493582409730">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Roberts seemed deeply offended at the idea that Congress barred fed recognition of same sex marriages because they don't like gay people
 Added: — AdamSerwer (@AdamSerwer) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ AdamSerwer/status/ 316952171759407104">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Kennedy cares deeply about federalism issues (more than Robts). Tells atty defending DOMA marriage "always considered a state police power."
 Added: — Jan Crawford (@JanCBS) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ JanCBS/status/ 316950834334281729">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Final update: <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23scotus" >#scotus</a> 80% likely to strike down <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23doma">#doma</a>. J Kennedy suggests it violates states’ rights; 4 other Justices see as gay rights.
 Added: — SCOTUSblog (@SCOTUSblog) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ SCOTUSblog/status/ 316943769708658688">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Final update: <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23scotus" >#scotus</a> 80% likely to strike down <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23doma">#doma</a>. J Kennedy suggests it violates states’ rights; 4 other Justices see as gay rights.</p>&mdash; SCOTUSblog (@SCOTUSblog) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ SCOTUSblog/status/ 316943769708658688">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Let's call it 83%—for plaintiff Edith Windsor's age: RT @<a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ scotusblog"> scotusblog</a> Final update: <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23scotus" >#scotus</a> 80% likely to strike down <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23doma">#doma</a>
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Let's call it 83%—for plaintiff Edith Windsor's age: RT @<a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ scotusblog"> scotusblog</a> Final update: <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23scotus" >#scotus</a> 80% likely to strike down <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23doma" >#doma</a></p>&mdash; Amy Davidson (@tnyCloseRead) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ tnyCloseRead/ status/316946068732518400">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p><a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23doma">#doma</a> in trouble at <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23scotus" >#scotus</a>. Kennedy suggests it violates states' rights. <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23ssm" >#ssm</a></p>&mdash; Jeffrey Toobin (@JeffreyToobin) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ JeffreyToobin/ status/316947763403317250">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Not totally clear if <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23SCOTUS" >#SCOTUS</a> gets to the merits on DOMA, but if so, Justice Kennedy and the four liberals justices raised tough Qs on law.</p>&mdash; Brent Kendall (@brkend) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ brkend/status/ 316951765557862401">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Heard on C-SPAN camera: "Paul Clement will not be coming out."I think that's true in several respects.</p>&mdash; Josh Blackman (@JoshMBlackman) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ JoshMBlackman/ status/316955876915298304">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
 Added: — Amy Davidson (@tnyCloseRead) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ tnyCloseRead/ status/316946068732518400">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23doma">#doma</a> in trouble at <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23scotus" >#scotus</a>. Kennedy suggests it violates states' rights. <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23ssm">#ssm</a>
 Added: — Jeffrey Toobin (@JeffreyToobin) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ JeffreyToobin/ status/316947763403317250">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter-tweet">Not totally clear if <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23SCOTUS" >#SCOTUS</a> gets to the merits on DOMA, but if so, Justice Kennedy and the four liberals justices raised tough Qs on law.
 Added: — Brent Kendall (@brkend) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ brkend/status/ 316951765557862401">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Heard on C-SPAN camera: "Paul Clement will not be coming out."I think that's true in several respects.
 Added: — Josh Blackman (@JoshMBlackman) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ JoshMBlackman/ status/316955876915298304">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Very funny video re: marriage &amp; procreation. Just say no... to GRAY MARRIAGE: <a href="http:// t.co/t6izUCKYuc" title="http:/ /bit.ly/ZpXEWZ" >bit.ly/ZpXEWZ</a> - <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23Prop8">#Prop8</a> <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a> <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23SSM" >#SSM</a></p>&mdash; David Lat (@DavidLat) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ DavidLat/status/ 316952117627740160">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> Added: <blockquote class="twitter-tweet">Very funny video re: marriage &amp; procreation. Just say no... to GRAY MARRIAGE: <a title="http:/ /bit.ly/ZpXEWZ" href="http:// t.co/t6izUCKYuc" >bit.ly/ZpXEWZ</a> - <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23Prop8">#Prop8</a> <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a> <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23SSM">#SSM</a>
 Added: — David Lat (@DavidLat) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ DavidLat/status/ 316952117627740160">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Roberta Kaplan addresses the media after arguing against <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a>, as Edie Windsor stands by (w scarf). <a href="http:// t.co/i9LrNVMwfG" title="http:/ /instagram.com/ p/XXimcPKFjg/ ">instagram.com/ p/XXimcPKFjg/ </a></p>&mdash; Chris Geidner (@chrisgeidner) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ chrisgeidner/ status/316951661178417152">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Roberta Kaplan addresses the media after arguing against <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23DOMA">#DOMA</a>, as Edie Windsor stands by (w scarf). <a title="http:/ /instagram.com/ p/XXimcPKFjg/" href="http:// t.co/i9LrNVMwfG" >instagram.com/ p/XXimcPKFjg/</a>
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>"In the midst of my grief I realized the US Government treated us as strangers." Edie Windsor press conference right now. She is amazing.</p>&mdash; Deb Rox (@debontherocks) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ debontherocks/ status/316953259304701952">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>Edith Windsor, on people who ask of marriage "why we want it and why we need it," says "it's a magic word ... it is magic"</p>&mdash; Rachel Weiner (@rachelweinerwp) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ rachelweinerwp/ status/316955370532777984">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote> 
Deleted: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet"><p>To put it simply, Edie is the star today. It was a wild scene outside <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23SCOTUS" >#SCOTUS</a> today.</p>&mdash; Chris Geidner (@chrisgeidner) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ chrisgeidner/ status/316958112642895873">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>  
 Added: — Chris Geidner (@chrisgeidner) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ chrisgeidner/ status/316951661178417152">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter-tweet">"In the midst of my grief I realized the US Government treated us as strangers." Edie Windsor press conference right now. She is amazing.
 Added: — Deb Rox (@debontherocks) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ debontherocks/ status/316953259304701952">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter- tweet">Edith Windsor, on people who ask of marriage "why we want it and why we need it," says "it's a magic word ... it is magic"
 Added: — Rachel Weiner (@rachelweinerwp) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ rachelweinerwp/ status/316955370532777984">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>
 Added: <blockquote class="twitter-tweet">To put it simply, Edie is the star today. It was a wild scene outside <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ search/%23SCOTUS" >#SCOTUS</a> today.
 Added: — Chris Geidner (@chrisgeidner) <a href="https:/ /twitter.com/ chrisgeidner/ status/316958112642895873">March 27, 2013</a></blockquote>

Note: Spaces may be added to comparison text to allow better line wrapping.

About victoriakwan

Victoria holds a J.D. from Columbia Law School and has recently completed a clerkship with a judge in Anchorage, Alaska. She tweets as @victoriakwan_ and posts primarily on legal issues, especially those involving the Supreme Court.

What do you think?